Vitamins and Supplements: Taken For Health Or Taken For A Ride?

Dr. White has been extensively involved in the field of diabetes since 1987. He has published two books, 17 book chapters, and over 70 manuscripts on the topic of diabetes. He has secured over $1,500,000 in diabetes-related research grants and has received numerous awards, including Teacher of the Year at Washington State University, College of Pharmacy in 1992 and 1996. Currently, he is serving as a diabetes consultant and primary care provider at the Indian Health Service Clinic in Wellpinit, Washington.

John R. White Jr., PA-C, Pharm.D.
Professor of Pharmacotherapy
WSU, College of Pharmacy, Spokane

| Apr 23, 2008

Does anyone living in our well-nourished country, eating a reasonable diet, really need to take vitamins, minerals, or herbs? Should a person with diabetes take them? If so, which ones and how much? When it comes to supplements, the answers are often unclear.

We do know the recommended daily allowances (RDA) for common vitamins and minerals: The RDA is defined as the amount needed to prevent deficiency diseases in about 98% of healthy individuals. Without this daily dose of vitamins, people develop such antique ailments as scurvy, rickets, beriberi, and pellagra.

Pellagra, for example, used to be common in corn-eating cultures like the southern United States prior to the mid-1900s. Because pellagra patients were photosensitive, they avoided the sun until they died a few years later. (Some medical historians believe that the disease gave rise to vampire legends because the victims went outside only at night.) In the early 1900s, it was proven that pellagra could be treated and prevented by vitamin B3 (niacin). We now know that the RDA of 14-16 mg per day will protect us from this deadly scourge.

It’s also true that niacin, when used in higher doses, can affect cholesterol levels and may even impact glucose control. Unfortunately, we don’t know much about the middle ground of vitamin dosages, between too little (deficiency diseases) and too much (vitamin toxicity). Non-vitamin and herbal supplements are also mostly uncharted territory. The federal government is helping a bit by funding an arm of the National Institutes of Health for Alternative Medicine, which finances some studies evaluating supplements. But because many of these compounds and herbs can’t readily be patented, the financial incentive for private industry to study them is simply not present.

Generally speaking, the nutrient recommendations for people with diabetes are the same as for those without diabetes. On the other hand, diabetes, particularly if uncontrolled, is associated with micronutrient deficiencies. When sugars are high, urination is increased to wash out the extra sugar, and vitamins are washed out as well. So perhaps people with diabetes should be a bit more aggressive in their decision to use supplements.

When deciding what to take, if anything, in the arena of supplements, consider the following tips.

Tips on Taking Supplements

Don’t rely on the fact that someone you know has been using a certain treatment for years. Remember Dr. James Craig, who correctly diagnosed George Washington with a throat infection and then began a series of blood-letting treatments. At the time, blood-letting was a well-regarded treatment that had been used for centuries.  Unfortunately, the ex-president soon expired, probably from being bled to death.

Don’t fall for this one: “It’s natural so it must be okay.” Strychnine, botulinum toxin, hemlock, deadly nightshade, elemental lead, elemental mercury are all natural and all deadly. Although most of today’s medications have molecular structures that are based on natural sources (plant-, mold-, or animal-derived), “natural” or “herbal” does not mean “safe.”

Watch out for off-brands of multi-vitamins. A recent study of vitamin E supplements found that a few of the brands contained less than ten percent of the stated amount. In addition to containing the stated amount, the supplement must be in a tablet, capsule, or effervescent form that will dissolve and can be absorbed from the small intestine into the blood stream. Choose a reputable brand such as GNC, TwinLab, Nature Made, and others. Look for something that contains 100% of the recommended daily allowance (RDA) for most of its constituents. Use that daily multiple vitamin to support a well-rounded and nutritious diet.

If you are going to start taking a new vitamin or supplement, be very skeptical of what you read on the Internet: Consider the source. Definitely talk to your doctor and your pharmacist. If your doctor or pharmacist thinks that all supplements are bunk, find a new doctor or pharmacist. Many vitamin and nutritional supplements are effective for various maladies, and many can be toxic or even cause drug interactions. You should be taken seriously, and supplements need to be taken seriously.

Be very careful with any substance (for example, cinnamon or niacin) that may affect your glycemic control.

Don’t substitute a vitamin or any form of supplement for a healthy lifestyle or for your prescription medication.

Remain vigilant. New research is reported virtually every day, and what we think is appropriate or effective today may be proven to be otherwise tomorrow.

And now for some specifics about supplements that may have applicability to diabetes. The following are some of the more popular, and perhaps more useful, supplements.

Vitamin C

Absolute vitamin C deficiency causes the disease scurvy, which is virtually unheard of outside of third-world countries. However, relative deficiency conditions exist more commonly. Several studies have demonstrated low levels of vitamin C in people with diabetes. Vitamin C may have a positive impact on the maintenance of blood normal blood pressure.  It is also an anti-oxidant and may have an impact on peripheral nerve function (reducing the progression of neuropathy).

While no long-term studies have been done to assess the impact of Vitamin C on peripheral neuropathy, one study from John Cunningham’s group at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst found that vitamin C supplementation of 250 or 500 mg per day blocked an enzyme (aldose-reductase) that has been implicated as one possible cause of peripheral neuropathy in patients with diabetes.

Vitamin C also caused a significant reduction in the concentration (back to normal) of sorbitol, which is promoted by the above-mentioned enzyme. Sorbitol has been linked to neuropathy. The researchers concluded that Vitamin C is an effective aldose-reductase inhibitor.

Pharmaceutical companies have spent millions of dollars seeking an effective and safe aldose-reductase inhibitor for the prevention or treatment of diabetic neuropathy. Several medications have been studied in people with diabetes, but none has yet proven safe and effective. Vitamin C may fit that bill. However, long-term studies to assess the impact of vitamin C on peripheral neuropathy have not been done.

High doses of vitamin C, greater than 4000 mg daily, may cause detrimental changes in glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes. A reasonable and safe dose is probably 250-1000 mg per day. The potential risk and cost of taking this amount of vitamin C is negligible, and benefits, while not conclusively proven, are possible.

Dietary sources of vitamin C are citrus fruit, green and red peppers, tomatoes, spinach, and collard greens.

Vitamin E

Vitamin E is a fat-soluble vitamin known to be a potent anti-oxidant. Vitamin E is actually a term applied to a group of eight compounds, all of which are synthesized by plants. The most potent constituent of the eight is d-alpha tocopherol. While in theory it would appear that high dose vitamin E should be useful, the reality is more complex.

A couple of early small studies suggested that vitamin E might prevent some of the long-term cardiovascular risk associated with diabetes. However, several larger, well-controlled trials (HOPE, MICRO-HOPE, and the Primary Prevention Project) each concluded that vitamin E supplementation had no measurable effect on cardiovascular or small vessel (kidney disease) disease in people with diabetes.

Still, many people decide to take the vitamin for other potential benefits. Daily doses of between 15 and 800 mg or IU (International Units) per day of alpha-tocopherol are probably reasonable. Vitamin E supplementation should be avoided in people treated with Coumadin or aspirin therapy, prior to consultation with their provider.

In foods, Vitamin E can be found in spinach, green peas, sweet potatoes, sunflower seeds, bean sprouts, blackeyed peas, almonds, peanuts, and cashews.

Alpha-Lipoic Acid

Alpha-lipoic acid or lipoic acid (LA) is a very potent anti-oxidant compound and is also a cofactor in several important biologic reactions. In Germany, it has been used for years to treat acute painful diabetic neuropathy. It has been evaluated in several well-controlled studies carried out in Germany, Russia, and the United States in patients with diabetes. In these trials (DEKAN Study, and The SYDNEY trial), LA was associated with improvement in autonomic and painful peripheral neuropathy.

Other studies have suggested that LA may improve glucose utilization in some patients with type 2 diabetes and may slow the progression of kidney damage. LA has not been associated with toxicity in doses used in these studies, typically 600 mg once or twice daily.

No dietary sources of alpha-lipoic acid are known.

Chromium Picolinate

Chromium is an essential element that is involved in the action of insulin. Severe chromium deficiency is rare. However, when compared with healthy non-diabetic people, individuals with diabetes, especially those with cardiovascular disease, have lower chromium levels. A couple of studies have found that low chromium concentrations in toenails (a measure of long-term intake) predict a higher incidence of heart attacks in otherwise healthy people.

Over ten small studies have evaluated the effects of chromium picolinate on glucose metabolism and blood fats in people with diabetes or impaired glucose tolerance, and in people without diabetes. In most of these studies, an increase in HDL (healthy cholesterol), an increase in the effectiveness of insulin, a reduction in triglyceride fats, and a reduction of glucose were observed. Doses of up to 1000 micrograms per day for as long as 64 months have reported no toxic effects.

Most of the studies evaluated 200 to 600 micrograms per day. A reasonable supplemental dose is probably 400 micrograms per day. Antacids or calcium carbonate can reduce the absorption of chromium and therefore should be taken at different times during the day. Talk with your physician and pharmacist prior to taking chromium picolinate, as you could potentially experience hypoglycemia and require a dose adjustment of your diabetes medications.

Dietary sources of chromium picolinate are whole grains, green beans, broccoli, processed meats, and bran cereals.

Cinnamon

Cinnamon made the news in 2003 with the publication of a study in the journal Diabetes Care. The study reported that cinnamon supplementation (1, 3, or 6 gms per day) was associated with a reduction in fasting glucose (18-29%), triglycerides (23-30%), and LDL cholesterol (7-27%) in patients with type 2 diabetes. Since then, two other studies have been published which reported no significant changes in fasting plasma glucose or A1c’s (glycosylated hemoglobin) with cinnamon administration.

Fewer than one hundred patients received cinnamon in all three studies combined, the studies were relatively short, and it is difficult to standardize cinnamon, all of which make it difficult to draw conclusions. If you do decide to try cinnamon, you certainly need to discuss it with your provider because if cinnamon does reduce blood sugar, you might have hypoglycemic episodes. A reasonable dose would probably be 1.5 to 2 grams per day; however, I would suggest not taking this until more is known about it.

Gamma-Linolenic Acid

Gamma linolenic acid (GLA) is a naturally occurring omega-6 fatty acid harvested from the seeds of evening primrose or borage. Several small studies in patients with type 1 or type 2 diabetes reported improvement in neuropathy with the administration of GLA. However, GLA may affect clotting.  Therefore, it should only be used under the supervision of your provider if you take any other medication that can affect bleeding times, such as aspirin, Coumadin, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, or others. Also, GLA can increase seizure risk in patients taking Thorazine, Stelazine or other phenothiazine drugs (used to control mental disorders). Doses used in the trials evaluating the effects of GLA on neuropathy were between 350 and 500 mg per day.

No dietary source of gamma-linolenic acid is known.

Magnesium

Magnesium is an essential trace mineral that is needed for over 300 biochemical reactions in the human body, including cellular energy production, the synthesis of genetic material (DNA and RNA), and the production of important proteins. Magnesium is important for nerve conduction, muscle contraction (including the heart), and the maintenance of appropriate tone of blood vessels.

Most of the magnesium in your body resides inside cells, so by the time that a routine blood test (which measures magnesium that is outside of cells) shows low magnesium levels, your body is quite depleted. Low magnesium is common in people with diabetes (25-38%). Magnesium deficiency may result in an inability to utilize insulin properly.

Several studies have evaluated the effects of magnesium on glucose levels in people with diabetes. The results of these studies are mixed, but generally when an effect was observed (which often was not the case), it was minimal. Magnesium supplementation may offer some protection for the heart, kidney, and nerves, but good studies are lacking. Magnesium toxicity is very rare except in people with kidney failure. Supplementation should not exceed 350 mg per day of elemental magnesium.

Dietary sources of magnesium are unprocessed grains, nuts, legumes, seafood, and chocolate (which is also high in sugar and fat).

Omega-3 Fatty Acids
(Fish oils and flaxseed oils)

Omega-3 fatty acids have been shown to reduce triglycerides, especially in people with high triglyceride levels. They also appear to have beneficial effects on the prevention of problems due to atherosclerosis (heart attacks, sudden death, and overall death). Several studies have also suggested a link between omega-3 fatty acid consumption and a reduction in rates of depression. It does not appear to matter if the omega-3 fatty acids are taken as a supplement or obtained via the consumption of fish.

The potential downside is that omega-3 fatty acids may cause a slight increase in bad cholesterol (LDL), so if you are going to use this supplement, make sure your provider monitors your cholesterol. Three to five grams of fish oil should be taken daily.

Omega-3 fatty acids are found in swordfish, flounder, herring, shark, halibut, salmon, tuna, cod, and others.

Pycnogenol

Pycnogenol is the US registered trademark for an extract from Pinus Pinaster (Maritime Pine Bark). This extract contains a group of bioflavanoids called procyanidins. Pycnogenol is a potent anti-oxidant, but probably has several mechanisms of action.

Pycnogenol has been shown to slow or prevent continued deterioration of retinal function in patients with diabetic retinopathy. It may also cause a slight reduction in systolic blood pressure. A study in the autumn of 2006 demonstrated an improvement in the functioning of small blood vessels in patients with diabetes: Capillary function was statistically significantly better in those taking Pycnogenol versus placebo over a period of four months. One study showed a slight improvement in erectile function after three months of treatment with Pycnogenol.

Long-term safety (greater than four months) has not been studied, but to date no adverse reactions have been reported. Suggested dose is 50 mg, three times daily.

Sources of Pycnogenol other than French maritime pine bark, are peanut skins, grape seed, and witch hazel bark.

Selenium

Several trials have now suggested a link between high serum selenium levels and diabetes. A study published earlier this year in the journal Diabetes Care, from the Welsh Center for Prevention, Epidemiology, and Clinical Research and Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, reported that high serum levels of selenium were positively associated with prevalence of diabetes. This study came three years after researchers at Cornell reported a link between high amounts of a selenium-containing enzyme and the development of a type 2-like syndrome in mice. Supplementation with selenium is not recommended at this time in non-selenium-deficient individuals.

Vanadium

Vanadium is characterized as a nonessential nutrient or a substance that is required in only miniscule amounts. No physiologic function has been described and no deficiency states have been identified in humans. There is no recommended daily allowance for vanadium. Vanadium exists in a couple of forms available as a supplement:  vanadyl sulfate and vanadyl metavanadate. While a few small studies have suggested that vanadium supplementation may be associated with slightly better glycemic control and improved insulin sensitivity, no well-designed randomized controlled trials have been completed. There is too little data to recommend the use of vanadium at this time.

Selected References

1) Franz MJ, Bantle JP, Beebe CA, et al. Evidence-Based Nutrition Principles and Recommendations for the Treatment and Prevention of Diabetes and Related Complications. Diabetes Care. 2002;25;1:148-190
2) Yeh GY, Kaptchuk TJ, Eisenberg DM, Phillips RS. Systematic Review of Herbs and Dietary Supplements for Glycemic Control in Diabetes. Diabetes Care. 2003;26;4:1277-1294
3) Bleys J, Navas-Acien A, Guallar E. Serum Selenium and Diabetes in U.S. Adults. Diabetes Care. 2007;30:829-834
4) Montori VM, Wollan PC, Farmer A, Dinneen SF. Fish Oil Supplementation in Type 2 Diabetes. A quantitative systematic review. Diabetes Care.2000;23;9:1407-1415
5) Pham AQ, Kourlas H, Pham DQ. Cinnamon Supplementation in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes. Pharmacotherapy. 2007;27;4:595-599
6) Cefalu WT, Hu FB. Role of Chromium in Human Health and Diabetes. Diabetes Care. 2004;27;11:2741-2751
7) De Lourdes Lima M, Rodrigues LE, Cruz T, Barbosa K, Pousada JC, Cangucu V. The Effect of Magnesium Supplementation in Increasing Doses on the Control of Type 2 Diabetes. Diabetes Care. 1998;21;5:682-686
8) Sacco M, Tognoni G, Pellegrini F, Nicolucci A, Rongaglioni MC, Avanzini F. Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Events with Low-Dose Aspirin and Vitamin E in Type 2 Diabetic Patients. Diabetes Care. 2003;26;12:3264-3272
9) Sydney Trial Authors. The Sensory Symptoms of Diabetic Polyneuropathy are Improved with alpha-lipoic acid. Diabetes Care. 2003;26;3:770-776

Click Here To View Or Post Comments

Categories: A1c Test, Blood Sugar, Diabetes, Diabetes, Food, Insulin, Low Blood Sugar, Medications, Supplements, Type 1 Issues, Type 2 Issues, Vitamins


Take the Diabetes Health Pump Survey
See What's Inside
Read this FREE issue now
For healthcare professionals only

You can view the current or previous issues of Diabetes Health online, in their entirety, anytime you want.
Click Here To View

See if you qualify for our free healthcare professional magazines. Click here to start your application for Pre-Diabetes Health, Diabetes Health Pharmacist and Diabetes Health Professional.

Learn More About the Professional Subscription

Free Diabetes Health e-Newsletter

Latest
Popular
Top Rated
Print | Email | Share | Comments (20)

You May Also Be Interested In...


Comments

Posted by Anonymous on 23 April 2008

>> The question is why haven't the drug
>> companies listened and provided us with one?

Simple answer: Because they can't turn it into a cash cow. I'm sure there are plenty of cures for many diseases not pursued because the financial motivation is not there. In fact, read the beginning of this article: The auther says explicitly the same thing.

'Big pharma' does not really want you cured because then they lose a customer: They want to 'maintain' you so you have to pay them over and over until you die.

And no, I am not a conspiracy theory buff. I'm just a realist.

Posted by Anonymous on 23 April 2008

I have type 2 and have used herbs for the 9 years I have had diabetes. My dr. is ok with this, but tells me I will eventually need to go on medicine. I am not sure why, the herbs work fine. One thing I know and my pharmacist told me the same thing. they never will cure it-there is no money in curing a disease.

Posted by blossom on 23 April 2008

I am a type 2- I have had diabetes for 9 years and use herbs. My dr. is ok with it, and says that someday I will need meds. I'm not sure why, the herbs work. My pharmacy person tells me that they will never cure diabetes- there is no money in curing anything. Too bad the ADA doesn't promote herb supplements- we had herbs before we had medicines and herbs DO work.

Posted by votres on 23 April 2008

My husband and I use all the above listed minerals, herbs etc. We take a total of 72 supplements each every day. When I have missed a week or so of them I do not function but with them I am strong and very healthy.
I am on the pump and my husband is on regular injections. My A1c is 5.2 not bad for a person having diabetes over 35 years.
This modern farming can't support us and we need to take these things to help us on our path.
I am 74 and my husband 78 and we are very healthy.

Posted by Anonymous on 24 April 2008

Good review. I would have thought that the first recommendation for people with diabetes whose blood sugar is out of control would be to work with their MD, diabetes educator, dietitian to try to achieve better blood sugar control. Also, GNC employees tend to think they are health care providers and would more likely promote unproven use of supplements.

Posted by nikkipowers on 24 April 2008

Actually there are vitamins made specially for those with diabetes which have the extra nutrients we need. I like a brand called Multibetic, because the pills are small and easy to swallow. Also they recommend that you take one pill in the morning and one in the evening so that you get 24 hour vitamin support (if you take too much of vit C for example at one time you just pee it out).
I find it at most of the drugstores where I shop - Walgreens and Rite Aid. It has much more vit c, lutein, magnesium than other vitamins and also has chromium, alpha lipoic acid and lots of B vitamins.

Posted by bdebruler on 24 April 2008

As a analytical chemist with type I diabetes, it is refreshing to see an article on supplements that is not based on testimonials. It can not be said often enough "Natural does not necessarily mean safe". Also, kudos for mentioning that you cannot easily standardize a dose of cinnamon. Plants make a vast array of molecules that can have pharmaceutical effects, and the amount of any given compound varies greatly on growing conditions. Never mind that there is often no certainty that the assumed plant compound is the effective component, or indeed has any effect at all!

p.s.
Do be careful with cinnamon, when putting it on your toast, try to stay within the crust! ;)

Posted by Anonymous on 24 April 2008

I don't eat toast, but I do like to put a little cinnamon in the coffee filter with the ground coffee.

Posted by Anonymous on 24 April 2008

I have type 2 and use B Clear Diabetic Energy Drink. It has a ton of vitamin B which I think everyone should be taking if you take metformin (see New Journal of Medicine article on Vitamin B depletion and metformim.)

It's also kind of nice becasue it curbs my monster afternoon sweet tooth craving.

Posted by Anonymous on 25 April 2008

I hope it was an oversight in not mentioning the Registered Dietitian with your statement: "If you are going to start taking a new vitamin or supplement, be very skeptical of what you read on the Internet: Consider the source. Definitely talk to your doctor and your pharmacist." Registered Dietitians (RD) are experts in the field of nutrition and identifying "junk science" on the internet. Some RD's even specialize in supplements. Many people, unfortunately, have no idea how an RD can help them navigate through the enormous amount of nutritional misinformation found on the internet, in the media, etc.

Posted by Anonymous on 26 April 2008

I was expecting to read something about Vit D. I´ve heard that people with DBT present decresed levels of that vit.

Posted by Anonymous on 26 April 2008

Good article. It is important to note that your registered dietitian or primary care provided may discourage or encourage the use of any of the vit/min/herbal/etc listed in the article based on your individiual needs.

Posted by Anonymous on 30 April 2008

There are so many different brands of vitamins out there. Can anyone tell me which vitamins would be rated the best or which vitamins I should avoid (name brand)?

Posted by debbie_lobato@yahoo.com on 5 May 2008

Ihave high sugars during the day vary low sugars during the night. what should I do.what causes this promlem.

Posted by Anonymous on 7 May 2008

I am 16 years old, and i dont vitamins at all. Is there any vitamins that i should be taking for my health?

Posted by Anonymous on 2 June 2008

I have been taking, an ounce a day of a drink "Mon-avie" which has done wonders for
my blood sugar control. Any feedback on this product?

Posted by Anonymous on 23 June 2008

I have used Beta Fast GXR Glucose Balance/extended release Gymnema silvester extract for over 8 years. At first, I used it with metformin. My HbA1c was over 8.0. I no longer use metformin, just Beta Fast, 2 tabs per day. My HbA1c remains below 6.0 for over 5 years. My dr. says it works great and to stick with it!

Posted by Anonymous on 7 July 2008

I'm 27 male, I finally got controlled of my glucose. Vitamin world helped me out on that. my cholestrol was good but my triglycerides was high so they recommended Omega 3 and Ultra Man 75. It has high doses of Vit E, B12, and Alpha Lipoic Acid. Being on Metformin you need alot of Vitamin B's so you won't get tired. i was up in the 180's in fasting, now i'm in the 90's. I'm going to try that Beta Fast too.

Posted by Ron Freeze on 7 August 2008

Hello,
Is anyone tried blueberry juice? I use 2-3 tablespoons of Kyani every morning and have alot more energy, I would like to know if this has any benefit for diabetes... I also also take omega 3 salmon oil after dinner .. oh yea ..diabetes is under control

Posted by Anonymous on 25 October 2009

I'm a diabetic. I believe the amount of vitamins and minerals I get in my diet is sufficient. However, I do believe in vitamin D3 and probiotics for myself, and not use and other otc supplements. Also, stop using acid reduction products like famotidine, since the probiotic takes care of acids and gas.


Add your comments about this article below. You can add comments as a registered user or anonymously. If you choose to post anonymously your comments will be sent to our moderator for approval before they appear on this page. If you choose to post as a registered user your comments will appear instantly.

When voicing your views via the comment feature, please respect the Diabetes Health community by refraining from comments that could be considered offensive to other people. Diabetes Health reserves the right to remove comments when necessary to maintain the cordial voice of the diabetes community.

For your privacy and protection, we ask that you do not include personal details such as address or telephone number in any comments posted.

Don't have your Diabetes Health Username? Register now and add your comments to all our content.

Have Your Say...


Username: Password:
Comment:
©1991-2014 Diabetes Health | Home | Privacy | Press | Advertising | Help | Contact Us | Donate | Sitemap

Diabetes Health Medical Disclaimer

The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. All content, including text, graphics, images, and information, contained on or available through this website is for general information purposes only. Opinions expressed here are the opinions of writers, contributors, and commentators, and are not necessarily those of Diabetes Health. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking medical treatment because of something you have read on or accessed through this website.