Home
- Eating Well (or at Least Not terribly) at Fast Food Resturants
You can view the current or previous issues of Diabetes Health online, in their entirety, anytime you want.
Click Here To View
See if you qualify for our free healthcare professional magazines. Click here to start your application for Pre-Diabetes Health, Diabetes Health Pharmacist and Diabetes Health Professional.
Latest Politics Articles
Popular Politics Articles
Highly Recommended Politics Articles
Email to a Friend
Send a link to this page to your friends and colleagues.
How Diabetes Topics in the News Can Start to Feel Like a Game of “Telephone”
Diabetes Health writer Patrick Totty wonders if the Byetta “controversy” is largely a media creation. Has the threshold for controversy these days stooped so low to reach so high?
A recent Wall Street Journal article shows once again how misinformation about diabetes-related topics can be spread by even the most expert journalists.
The article, headlined "Eli Lilly to Pay for Right to Sell Diabetes Treatment Outside U.S.," begins, "Eli Lilly & Co. will pay Amylin Pharmaceuticals Inc. for the right to sell a controversial diabetes treatment outside of the U.S." (our italics)
The article discusses Lilly purchasing the right to sell a long-acting form of Byetta outside of the United States. Byetta, the brand name for exenatide, has approximately 700,000 users in the United States. Introduced in 2005, it is a proven means of controlling blood sugar levels in people with diabetes and helping many of them lose weight.
The version Lilly will sell abroad, called Byetta LAR and taken once weekly, is now undergoing the approval process by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
The article jumps the track when it notes that when Amylin reported that Byetta performed well against a rival drug, Januvia, "that news came after recent reports of deaths from severe pancreatitis in patients on currently marketed twice-daily doses of Byetta. Amylin has repeatedly stated there is no proven relationship between Byetta and pancreatic side effects."
Those two sentences are the vaunted "balance" that journalists always talk about when they write a "he said/she said" piece.
Here's the problem with it:
- The source of the "recent reports"-the FDA-is never identified.
- The number of deaths from severe pancreatitis in patients taking Byetta is not mentioned (six).
- The number of people taking Byetta who have also experienced severe, but not fatal, pancreatitis is not mentioned (30).
- The total number of people taking Byetta is never mentioned (approx. 700,000).
- The difference between correlation (taking Byetta and later getting severe pancreatitis) and causation (taking Byetta and therefore getting severe pancreatitis) is never mentioned or explored.
Admittedly, the article's writer was probably facing space constraints and had to resort to the shorthand explanation above. The problem with that shorthand is it soon becomes an accepted stand-in for more thoughtful and thorough explanations of controversial topics.
In fact, the "controversy" is largely a media creation. Even if Byetta could be proven as the cause of six fatal cases of pancreatitis among several hundred thousand users over a three-year period, we are talking about roughly one in every 12,000 users.
Is the threshold for controversy these days that low?
Disclaimer: Contributing writer Patrick Totty has type 2 diabetes and takes metformin and a sulfonylurea. He has never taken Byetta. He has no investments in and no personal or professional relations with Amylin or Lilly. He dislikes junk science and hates to see it repeated in a good newspaper like the Wall Street Journal.
Categories: Blood Sugar, Byetta, Community, Diabetes, Diabetes, Food, Losing weight, Politics, Type 2 Issues
You May Also Be Interested In...
-
Diabetes Health
Diabetes Health is the essential resource for people living with diabetes- both newly diagnosed and experienced as well as the professionals who care for them. We provide balanced expert news and information on living healthfully with diabetes. Each issue includes cutting-edge editorial coverage of new products, research, treatment options, and meaningful lifestyle issues.
-
Topics
- Diabetic / Diabetes Health
- Type 1 / 1.5 Diabetes
- Type 2 Diabetes
- Blood Glucose / Sugar
- High/Low Blood Sugar / Fast Acting Glucose
- Insulin- Pumps, Pens & Syringes
- Continuous Glucose Monitors, CGM, Infusion Sets
- Type 2 Medications
- Hyperglycemia
- Hypoglycemia
Comments
Good article. One point to keep in mind is that this is not unusual for the media. This is not to make an excuse for them, but it is fairly standard operating mode even in writing about non-technical topics.
Just a test.
ooze-grounded a test. get hold of bumf on newborn babe nourish, cradle caps, babe paste mindfulness and other parenthood and rearing resources from . test
Hi!
Where can i read more about indian pharmacy
Weight Loss treatment?
Add your comments about this article below. You can add comments as a registered user or anonymously. If you choose to post anonymously your comments will be sent to our moderator for approval before they appear on this page. If you choose to post as a registered user your comments will appear instantly.
When voicing your views via the comment feature, please respect the Diabetes Health community by refraining from comments that could be considered offensive to other people. Diabetes Health reserves the right to remove comments when necessary to maintain the cordial voice of the diabetes community.
For your privacy and protection, we ask that you do not include personal details such as address or telephone number in any comments posted.
Don't have your Diabetes Health Username? Register now and add your comments to all our content.
Register...
Register your Diabetes Health Username here.
Have Your Say...