Suicide Rate in Men with Type 1

Depressed Young Man

| May 30, 2014

The National Institute for Health (NIH) reports that people with diabetes who suffer from depression, are at a higher risk, in experiencing extreme symptoms from their diabetes.

The suicide rate for men with type1 diabetes was published in June of 1994. In the last few days, we have had 4 people comment on suicide from this dated and pertinent article. I am hoping my inspiring subscribers, you, can shed light and offer hope to these honest and courageous posts.

June 1994- Diabetes Health Interview.

A study from Odense University, in Odense, Denmark, investigating suicides among men with IDDM has discovered that the suicide rate is higher than expected (March, 1994, Diabetes Care).

The study involved men born between 1949 and 1964 who were diagnosed with type 1 diabetes before the age of 20 and who had died prior to January 1st, 1991. Of the 168 deaths investigated, twelve were officially classified as suicide. Using a previous study of the general Danish population as a control, the expected number of suicides was one. The study also looked at deaths classified as unknown cause, and found three possible and two probable suicides, as well as one accidental death that could be reclassified as a probable suicide. Additionally, 15 deaths occurred in connection with the onset of diabetes.

This is the largest population-based study of suicide in people with IDDM, and the results indicate the importance of recognizing depression in patients with diabetes and treating it appropriately.

 

 

Click Here To View Or Post Comments

Categories: Depression, Diabetes, Diabetes Care, diabeteshealth.com, IDDM, Men, Nadia Al-Samarrie, National Institute for Health (NIH), Suicide, Suicide Rate, symptoms


Take the Diabetes Health Pump Survey
See What's Inside
Read this FREE issue now
For healthcare professionals only
  • What's on the Horizon with Diabetes Research and Therapy
See the entire table of contents here!

You can view the current or previous issues of Diabetes Health online, in their entirety, anytime you want.
Click Here To View

See if you qualify for our free healthcare professional magazines. Click here to start your application for Pre-Diabetes Health, Diabetes Health Pharmacist and Diabetes Health Professional.

Learn More About the Professional Subscription

Free Diabetes Health e-Newsletter

Latest
Popular
Top Rated

Latest Suicide Articles

Print | Email | Share | Comments (26)

You May Also Be Interested In...


Comments

Posted by Anonymous on 9 July 2008

My son recently committed suicide at the age of 23. He had Type 1 diabetes since the age of 12. He had great control while he lived at home but once he went to college, he didn't take care of himself like he should have. As college students tend to do, he drank with his friends and ate what he wanted without testing his blood sugar on a regular basis. The night he shot himself, he had been out drinking and got into a fight with his best friend. After his death, I found his meter which showed numbers ranging from 400-500. Would this explain his death?

Posted by Anonymous on 26 September 2008

I'm 37, had type 1 for 24 years. I can only imagine the pain over losing your son, as I've imagined how much my attempted suicide several years ago would have devestated my family and friends. I overdosed on insulin and was found by a friend and taken to the hospital. High and low blood sugars can cause severe mood swings and, as I've noticed, alcohol increases this problem. I've damaged relationships by sugar levels causing me to become depressed, irrationally angry and frustrated. It is extremely difficult to explain to a friend who experiences this behavior that you are sorry and an unbalance in your system is mostly to blame. People forgive but never forget. I've recently lost my girlfriend due to irrational behavior during a sugar low of 30 after drinking, when I tried to explain and apologize she said she could not be with someone who could have unpredictable mood swings. I wanted to die, remembering many times in my life that I've lost control and felt helpless. I'm starting a stressful new job and I'm scared. High and low blood sugar levels can turn a happy, stable diabetic to severely depressed and confused, alcohol exaggerates this and a fight with a best friend on top of it is totally overwhemling. Honestly, I stay alive now for my parents and siblings, I could not live this life for myself.

Posted by Anonymous on 29 September 2008

A few days ago, my father-in-law committed suicide by shooting himself. He was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes when he was 14, which was 47 years ago. In the last 15 years of his life, he was increasingly unable to control his blood sugar levels, and this lack of control apparently seeped into the other parts of his life. Only days earlier he seemed happy, had plans with us and many friends in the near and distant future, and gave no indication of any problems. The why is still unclear, but reading these articles and posts seems to shed a little light on such a complicated problem. Thank you.

Posted by Anonymous on 30 September 2008

A few days ago, my father-in-law committed suicide by shooting himself. He was diagnosed with type 1 diabetes when he was 14, which was 47 years ago. In the last 15 years of his life, he was increasingly unable to control his blood sugar levels, and this lack of control apparently seeped into the other parts of his life. Only days earlier he seemed happy, had plans with us and many friends in the near and distant future, and gave no indication of any problems. The why is still unclear, but reading these articles and posts seems to shed a little light on such a complicated problem. Thank you.

Posted by Anonymous on 10 January 2009

My father committed suicide just before the holidays. He had increased health problems due to diabetes that led to depression and later his death. He had symptoms of passing out in the night trying to get to the refrigerator to eat something, etc.
The autopsy report stated he had an enlarged thyroid. This happens later in life w/ some diabetics b/c the thyroid is an "autoimmune" organ and part of the endocrine system w/ the pancreas.
Reading more on hyperthyroidism and "Thyroid Storms", it is now logical that the thyroid condition was making the depression worse and causing these episodes.
I now spend everyday learning more and more about the disease of diabetes mellitus and what it does to your body.
I pray for all those affected by suicide. Unfortunately, it was a permanent solution to a temporary state of mind.

Posted by Anonymous on 15 April 2009

I have a close friend who is suffering with type 1 diabetes. He is 24 years old, and was diagnosed when he was 19. I know it has only been 5 years, but his depression is uncontrollable- and I feel like he has given up. He smokes all the time, and seems not to care about his health. He eats what he wants, and his mood swings are dramatic and occur often. I love him, and I dont know what I can do to help without pushing him away. His mom is on her last string, he has stopped listening to his family and they have asked me for help. Any suggestions?

Posted by Anonymous on 19 May 2009

I have had diabetes for over 30 yrs. It has been very difficult and I have done everything I could possibly do to stay healthy. I am in the best physical shape of my life @ 51 because I found out a few months ago that I have a gluten allergy and severe magnesium deficiency both can related to diabetes and make your moods and blood sugars uncontrolable. I still suffer from the swings. Please be a good friend and look up the symptoms of both. We need all of the help we can get. Forgive us sometimes for we know not what we do and our behavior hurts us more then you can imagine.

Posted by Anonymous on 25 May 2009

Im 17 years old and I got diabetes when i was 10 years old on my birthday. It was the most confusing day in my life, and I often ask myself "what is there to live for?", or "why me?". The thing about diabetes that Ive noticed is that when things are down and out, diabetes makes them 10 times worse. Reading all these stories about suicide really makes me understand how others like me really feel, and I thinks thats important to know. The only thing worth living for in my life is my family and the future, and what it possibly holds for me. If you know anyone with diabetes, don't take their presence for granted because its an everyday dtruggle for them to push forward with the most simplest tasks at hand.

Posted by Anonymous on 18 August 2009

It doesn't surprize me. In fact, I am surprized the suicide rate is not higher. When I became diabetic at age 21 my father told me that whatever I planned to do with my life, to forget it--I would never be able to take the stress of living in the real world as a diabetic, especially since my family has a high incidence of mental illness even without the diabetes. Later my mother wondered why that should make me go into a state of chronic depression. A priest told me God gave me diabetes to keep me out of the priesthood because I would more hard than good in this world if I were to become a priest. I have never met a diabetic success story. They only exist in diabetic journals. The irony is the harder I struggle with the depression, the more difficult it is to properly control my diabetes. Then the doctors lay a guilt trip on you for not managing your diabetes properly. The insurance company insists that I only need to test my blood sugars once, rather than four times a day. The professors and other graduate students wonder why I don't get through graduate school according to schedule, because, of course, they believe the success stories in the diabetic journals, etc., etc. The longer I live with diabetes the stronger the impression I have that suicide is ultimately inevitable. After I am dead, everyone who knew me will wonder why I just didn't try harder.

Posted by Anonymous on 2 September 2009

I sympathise with everyone here. I'm a 30 year old with type 1 diabetes. I have been diabetic since 17. The doctor ignored my symptoms and pleas for help for ages and I ended up in hospital on a drip with severe hypoglycemia. It has affected my education as during school I was almost passing out. I had told the teacher I was ill but she said I was ill in the head and people bullied me because I was underweight saying it was an eating disorder etc. I can't imagine what the mis diagnosis holds for the long term. As if the lethargic crappy feelings of not being able to control my blood sugars and nearly dying infront of my boyfriend isn't enough, I have to live with the possibility of going blind, having kidney failure, heart failure, messed up pregnacy and /or amputations in the future. My friends and family too don't understand why I act the way I do sometimes. Also my family are prudish and ask me not to inject so as not to humiliate them. Although my mum is better my sister was horrible once. I've made mistakes at work due to hypos, hallucinated due to hypos, been aggressive and been arrested because of it. Lost relationships with friends etc. Nearly died due to two faulty metres with my boyfriend in tears. Luckily he is understanding and sticks by me. Doctors and nurses tell me I'm fine when I'm not and aren't helpful. I feel exhausted, angry, a sense of hopelesness and fear for the future every day of my life. I have to say I stive for a cure for it. Type 2 can be cured but so they say not type 1. I hate what I have and yes have in the past contemplated suicide. Diabetes and depression go hand in hand. However I am fighting hard. Also God didn't give (last poster) diabetes on purpose. It is a man made disease. Scientifically it says it is caused by environmental factors and /or genetics. Think chemicals we've used, radiation, saturated fat etc. WE CAUSED ALL THESE DISEASES NOT GOD. What we are today is the result of our evil doings in the past. I fight this disease every step of the way. Today diving is now possible, without complications, you can be under certain circumstances and if you are prepared to fight hard, be accepted in the fire service now without predudice. Medication has improved immensely since the olden days with a syringe. There is hope please don't give up. These days communication is better, there is more understanding and hopefully with this less suicides. In the past however unfortunately this wasn't the case and you were told "you are imagining this, or you are "non compliant" etc. and you felt isolated and trapped with the disease. God rest the souls of those who suffered this way and suffered through accidental death also. Please be known there is still hope. If I can fight it and stay strong so can you all. Peace and love Rach

Posted by Rachael on 2 September 2009

Anon 18 August. How old are you now? Firstly God didn't give you this diabetes on purpose - it is man made. What happens to us today is the result of our own evil doings in the past, think chemicals and pesticides, warfare, radiation etc. I am a 30 year old type 1 diabetic. I sympathise with everyone here that has posted. God rest the souls of those that have left because they felt frustrated, angry, helpless and exhausted with what they have. I only know because I was diagnosed at 17 and this is what the so called professionals do is tell you "you are non compliant" or "you are imagining these symptoms" or "you are doing fine" when you aren't. I was bullied at school for being underweight I was desperate for an answer and kept seeing my doctor only to be ignored. Eventually I screamed at him and he told me straight away it could be three things. He didn't seem to care, the next minute I was rushed to hospital with US 675(mg/dl) or UK 37.5(mmol/L). I had suffered negligence that's for sure. Also I don't know what that holds for my future. I've lost relationships with friends etc. due to how I've acted through diabetes too, I've nearly died and lay there helpless unable to speak while my boyfriend cried then next minute paramedics were pumping glucose into me to keep me alive. I've lost jobs, made mistakes been arrested all to do with diabetes and few people understand. In the past people were isolated had poor medication, no communication or understanding from others. They would pretend they are fine (and still do) so that their closest ones don't worry. Then it becomes all too much and they can't cope with feeling helpless, lethargic, lonely, isolated, trapped, fearful of future complications such as amputations, blindness, kidney failure, still birth, oversized baby, miscarriage, all due to diabetes, trying desperately to control it to feel NORMAL, "HELP" they scream please let me be NORMAL!!!! Please understand me please can I not feel like crap every single day of my life. I have contemplated suicide in the past, even now my doctors are crap and my sister tells me to inject in the toilets as to not "embarress her and behave incorrectly". I don't eat or drink with her or her friends now. My mum used to tell me the same and I would say "ok I'll just have a convulsion infront of you instead suffer immense sickness and pain, just so you don't have to have your daughter stick a pen in herself to save her life!". She soon got used to the idea and doesn't mention it now! I pray and hope and strive to get a cure. I research and research. These days I hear of juveniles going on a raw food diet and reversing type 1 also some vitamin D and niocitin or something helps too upon first diagnoses. However for me who's had it for years apparantly it's irreversable but I do not give up hope. People are slowly becoming more understanding of diabetes, there is more advanced medication to help us now also attitudes are changing. This and the fact I have a loving boyfriend who understands and want to provide positivity to others who have suffered and still do like me, makes me want to carry on and FIGHT this disease. Fight it and I CONTROL IT rather than the other way around. It's hard though but after 13 years why should I stop now? Peace and love Rach.

Posted by Rachael on 2 September 2009

I should add, there are some online forums etc. now which have helped me get through a lot of struggles with diabetes and unhelpful doctors etc. Also I fight for a normal life. There are still blanket bans against diabetes such as firefighter etc. however I've been told by a type 1 diabetic that he got through to be a firefighter after much fighting. Also people have fought to be on animal insulin as they have been allergic to synthetic causing erratic blood sugars and mood swings. I am currently on animal and synthetic and am considering the pump. After suffering 5 night time hypos, exhaustion and insomnia almost every day and losing my job in the UK I qualify for the pump. I haven't mentioned spasms and fear of having a child as part of the illness too. However I WILL NOT GIVE UP. It is important to keep the faith, and not give up hope. I aim to be a veterinary nurse in the near future rather than in the financial sector. Not because I believe diabetes stops me but to be a financial sector worker is not in my heart. Also in some ways diabetes has made me gain more inner strength, and more aware of my diet and what I'm eating and so I don't curse completely what I have. Also at the moment my blood sugars are a little erratic but good diet and exercise is helping me a lot. Hope this comforts most if not all families who have lost, diabetics and friends etc. Rach

Posted by Rachael on 2 September 2009

Anon 15 April 2009. I hope you manage to read this / post back etc. Your friend is in a kind of state of denial. He does not want to accept he has what he has. He smokes and drinks etc. partly to act cool and normal but also as a coping mechanism. Reminding him of the dangers isn't going to do any good. Rather kind of coax him into doing positive things such as ride a bike with you, or join a healthy cooking class together or something that will benefit his diabetes but at the same time you both will enjoy. You should want to do the activity too, make out you need him there as a friend and don't mention the diabetes. He'll figure out eventually what you are trying to do. Exercise and good diet are a plus point in diabetes. Also good mood foods are mung beans, lobster, turkey, asparagus, sunflower seeds, cottage cheese, pineapple, tofu, spinach and bananas - the foods containing the highest levels of tryptophan. tryptophan helps you produce the hormone serotonin which stops us feeling depressed basically. Sometimes these levels can drop and that's when the doc prescribes prozac or something. However the natural alternative is all the foods above, and it is just as effective believe me! I've done prozac, eventually I felt numb and angry, now I do "mood foods" so offer your friend a snack like this every so often. All these snacks are fine for a diabetic. Also he should do carb counting, helping to balance the sugars more. However don't introduce all this at once. More info below. I'm off to bed now.

Read more: http://holistic-nutrition.suite101.com/article.cfm/the_top_ten_good_mood_foods#ixzz0PzszeDSm

Posted by Anonymous on 10 November 2009

I can say that there is not a day that goes bye without me thinking about my diabetes and suicide....25 years at 44....all down hill from here.

Posted by Anonymous on 15 December 2010

What happened to all the posts that were deleted after this last post of Nov,2009? If you don't like the comments don't ask the question.

Posted by Anonymous on 27 December 2010

I'm in my early thirties, I've had type one diabetes since I was three. I was doing good for a long time with my health, an athlete even. Now, just in the last couple years some horrible things have happened, and I can't afford it anyway. I can't afford dental care, insurance, or any standard of living that is worth living in, I even went without heat for a while. I don't see any chance what so ever for any kind of happiness from this point forward. I'll most likely be ending my life soon, either by shooting or hanging myself.

Posted by Anonymous on 17 March 2011

I appreciate the honesty and heartfelt thoughts from you all. I have been a diabetic for 40 years and always toughed it out. is'nt that what we are supposed to do? Howevr I have grown tired of the fight, now 53. Thank you for those speaking of suicide. Somehow it provides some relief and comfort. I too think of taking my life every day. It's exausting.
Thank you

Posted by Anonymous on 20 May 2012

I am 35 years old and have had type 1 Diabetes since I was 8. Reading these stories, I can really relate. I agree that depression gets much worse when my blood sugar levels are out of control. My mood swings are out of control also. I have lost almost all of my old friends due to this, but I dont think any of them understand that Diabetes has anything to do with my behavior. I also recently split with my longtime girlfriend because she couldn't deal with my mood swings and depression any longer. I have been having suicidal thoughts for most of the past 8 years. I wish more people would bring to light these problems of many diabetics.

Posted by Anonymous on 21 May 2014

My first suicide attempt was whe I was 19, before the diabetes. Now I'm 24, 1 year of type 1 diabetes. I don't think about suicide more often then before, every day, just like before. But now I think that insulin overdose is the best way to commit suicide for me. The main problem about it is not to be found overdosed during the first hours, to avoid possibility of occasional surviving. I have married 4 years ago, I have a 1.5 y.o. son and a job, that I love. That stops me for now, but I'm not sure about the future. I think about suicide again and again. I can't stop.

Posted by Anonymous on 27 May 2014

My son is 15 years old, and was diagnosed when he was 10. He was diagnosed with depression a few years ago and has been in a mental hospital twice for suicidal ideations. To add to it, his father has PTSD but isn't being treated for it. I have done everything I can to support him, but in my heart, I have a feeling he will take his life before he hits 30 years old, and that's why he doesn't take care of himself. He doesn't worry about long term damage. His last A1C was 13.7.

Posted by Anonymous on 30 May 2014

Hi I'm 23 years old and turning 24 in august. I've had type 1 diabetes since i was 7 years old for almost 7 years now. My father has been getting bent outta shape often too much because i go low way too much having seizures often. Because of my type 1 diabetes it's giving me other problems that prevent me from taking care of myself permanently. I feel like i wanna commit suicide sometime in the future and promising that. I feel really depressed with type 1 diabetes and so unhappy about it. Committing suicide will be my final answer sometime in the future. No question about it.

Posted by Anonymous on 31 May 2014

Sad to read these comments but have to agree. At first going into hospital with dka made me change my life. Stopped using drugs+alcohol, smoking, eating healthy & plenty of exercise. But it does grind you down. I feel you comments. Recently tried suicide with tablets(took wrong ones) then cutting both wrists(cut in wrong place). Now i know to smash my insulin, take handfuls of sleepers and sleep till ketosis does me

Posted by Anonymous on 1 June 2014

I think it is important to emplore organizations like the JDRF, and doctors to cease all mention of a cure. As a T1 for 32 years I have heard it all and for me, it makes me very depressed when the reality is there is no cure and there won't be for a very very long time. If at all since not one auto-immune disease has been cured. I'm saddened for the families that have lost a loved one due to depression associated with this illness. Researchers remain in the lab curing nice because it is safe. Humans are the ultimate test and why stop the gravy train. Unless you have T1 you really can't understand the toll it takes on the individual. The DCCT study that was done proved that even with tight controls complications are still a reality and tight control is extremely difficult, at least for me.

The media is also very irresponsible in how they portray medical research. They sensationalize the headlines which has an emotional impact on those with the disease and while some might be better able to process and handle it, they are the exception. Diablo mean is also a huge problem in diabetic girls.

Bottom line, we need organizations to be responsible in how they communicate, especially anything 'cure' related. Simply saying it's still years away at the end of an article is garbage. The press releases are for share holders or to make a product look attractive for a sale. Otherwise, do we really need to know about it? Tell me when it's at the bedside curing humans, not mice.

Posted by Anonymous on 16 June 2014

I'm 56yr old. I have had Type 1 DM since I was 9. I thought I was doing well with the occasional bouts of deep depression. I tried cutting my wrist when I was 16. I stopped cause it hurt. I have not tried to do that again In the past 5yrs,I have thought seriously about taking my life. My biggest fear is that pain would be involved. I now have Stage 3 kidney failure. Dialysis is evitable.. I refuse to do this. My Mom went through this and it was not pretty. I rather have quality of life,not quantity. I have had 2 MIs with stent placement. I am most afraid that I will have another or have a stroke. I pray that if this happens,I hope I don't survive. Who wants there butt washed and cleaned by someone else! I don't want to be a burden on anyone,esp my family. I think others incl family, say all the right stuff don't think what it would mean for their life. We are suppose to say things that will let us know we are wanted,but they don't think ahead. I have to think seriously about is and when I want to leave this earth. I want to go on my terms and not the diabetes.

Posted by Anonymous on 23 June 2014

It is so ridiculous to attribute the cause of type 1 diabetic suicide to 'depression,' as though what prompts it is some mental illness rather than the diabetes itself! It is quite frustrating trying to control diabetic hyperglycemia, since doctors who purport to 'manage' the condition have no idea how life-consuming the effort can be and how lethal the heightened risk of severe hypoglycemia can be. If you look at the diabetic suicide statistics, you will probably find that many of the suicides are due to diabetic renal failure, which causes one quarter of its patients ultimately to commit suicide (withdrawal of treatment) rather than continue.

Posted by Anonymous on 4 July 2014

Hi Im 42yrs old , I have been a type 1 for 13yrs , I was pregnant with my 2nd child while I was sick for at least 4 months ,I told my midwife for months I had blurred eyes,& I couldn't stop drinking she did nothing until I went for my 6 month blood tests,i was put in hospital for about 4 days ,I new nothing about diabetes back then I was told it would go when I had my baby , they said it did when I had my baby ,I became very sick & went to the doctors & they put me in Hospital it was only then they told me I was a type 1 , some of them have no idea what they are doing,to be honest a lot of health professionals have no idea ive learnt most everything myself from living with this disease,i have had quite good control over the years, way more problems with lows about 6 years ago I starting having fits at night when I became low but I always woke myself up while this was happening , one night I had 3 I cant understand why I never died my doctor said I must of had a built in alert to wake myself up as I was home alone with my kids due to a breakup in my marriage , I was put onto Lantis & I never had a fit again, Type 1 Diabetes is a very complicated disease,this is the first time I have read these posts , there are a lot of people commenting they have depression from having type 1 & offen have suicide thoughts,i dont believe its all due to depression I believe its due to your blood sugars getting low as I myself have had suicide thoughts over the years & I don't have depression when your blood sugars get low sometimes it just hits you until you have some jellybeans & then you are fine,they should be doing a study on low blood sugars & what it does to your brain as I believe this is why people are killing themselves.


Add your comments about this article below. You can add comments as a registered user or anonymously. If you choose to post anonymously your comments will be sent to our moderator for approval before they appear on this page. If you choose to post as a registered user your comments will appear instantly.

When voicing your views via the comment feature, please respect the Diabetes Health community by refraining from comments that could be considered offensive to other people. Diabetes Health reserves the right to remove comments when necessary to maintain the cordial voice of the diabetes community.

For your privacy and protection, we ask that you do not include personal details such as address or telephone number in any comments posted.

Don't have your Diabetes Health Username? Register now and add your comments to all our content.

Have Your Say...


Username: Password:
Comment:
©1991-2014 Diabetes Health | Home | Privacy | Press | Advertising | Help | Contact Us | Donate | Sitemap

Diabetes Health Medical Disclaimer

The information on this site is not intended or implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. All content, including text, graphics, images, and information, contained on or available through this website is for general information purposes only. Opinions expressed here are the opinions of writers, contributors, and commentators, and are not necessarily those of Diabetes Health. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay seeking medical treatment because of something you have read on or accessed through this website.